Unless you're a Supergirl fan. Most fans of Kara Zor-el, that I know of(including myself), want to chuck 'Supergirl's Secret Marriage' into the same dumpster that Liefield 'art' goes into.
I don't think the standard for what goes in and does not should be what stories anyone likes. "Supergirl's Secret Marriage" is a terrible story, but it is a part of the same shared "history" as all of the other pre-reboot stories and should be included.
True. True. About the pre-reboot and what criteria a story should be used to place in the enclylopedia
I tend to ignore what happened after/during the Crisis, due to other reasons. The Crisis was the first step in the total dismantling of the old pre-Crisis DCU. Millenium(removing the Guardians), the fall of the GLC, the death of Jason Todd, Superman & Batman & Wonder Woman retroactively removed from the JLofA as members, and so on. That twilight era between Crisis and re-boot is what's causing all the glitches in the current DCU. The fall of the GLC and loss of the Guardians causes problems for the pre-boot Legion of Super-Heroes at any rate(Universo anyone?).