With all of the help given here I was able to assemble my list. For some odd reason I couldn't gain access to the Grand Comic Database but I did find another site that was simply freaking awesome. Some of you are probably aware of it but I post a link anyway.
Mike's Amazing World of DC ComicsThis site is great. I found it using the Google search that MatterEaterLad suggested.
Anyway, even though Lee Semmens listed the links to the Grand Comic Database entries I decided to post the fruits of my efforts here. A few notes first:
-As you will notice I use the same type of issue numbering system that
The Great Superman Book used. It just seemed more professional and appealed to my anal-retentive sensibilites.
-Also the first few stories from both volumes lacked an identifiable story title. I went with
Mike's Amazing World of DC Comics on this, so that is why they appear in brackets.
And here we go.
Superman: From the ‘30s to the ‘70s- Bonanza Books New York- 1971- Fourth Edition
Dedication by Carmine Infantino, Publisher Superman Comics
Introduction by E. Nelson Bridwell, Editor National Periodicals Comics
[“Superman, Champion of the Oppressed”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #1- Summer 1939
[“War in San Monte”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #1/2- Summer 1939
[“The Challenge of Luthor”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #4- Spring 1940
[“The Dukalia Spy Ring”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #10/4- May/June 1941
[“The Light”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #13- November/December 1941
[“The Archer”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #13/2- November/December 1941
[“Saboteurs from Napkan”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #15/2- March/April 1942
“How Clark Kent Met Lois Lane”- Adventure Comics #128- May 1948
“Man or Superman?”- Superman (Vol. 1) #17- July/August 1942
“Case of the Funny Paper Crimes”- Superman (Vol. 1) #19- November/December 1942
“Superman, Matinee Idol”- Superman (Vol. 1) #19/4- November/December 1942
“America’s Secret Weapon”- Superman (Vol. 1) #23- July/August 1943
“The Mysterious Mr. Mxyztplk!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #30/4- September/October 1944
“Lois Lane, Superwoman”- Superman (Vol. 1) #45- March/April 1947
“The Origin of Superman”- Superman (Vol. 1) #53- July/August 1948
“Black Magic on Mars”- Superman (Vol. 1) #62- January/February 1950
“The Mightiest Team in the World”- Superman (Vol. 1) #76- May/June 1952
“The Girls in Superman’s Life”- Superman (Vol. 1) #78/4- September/October 1952
“The Terrible Trio”- Superman (Vol. 1) #88/3- March 1954
“The Girl in Superman’s Past!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #129/3- May 1959
“The Untold Story of Red Kryptonite!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #139/3- August 1960
“The Son of Bizarro!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #140- October 1960
“The Orphan Bizarro!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #140/2- October 1960
“The Supergirl Bizarro!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #140/3- October 1960
“Superman Meets Al Capone!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #142/2- January 1961
“Bizarro Meets Frankenstein!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #143/3- February 1961
“Superboy’s First Public Appearance!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #144/2- April 1961
“The Pied Piper of Steel”- Action Comics #398- March 1971
“Superman Breaks Loose”- Superman (Vol. 1) #233- January 1971
“Superman, You’re Dead…Dead…Dead!”- Action Comics #399- April 1971
“Duel of Doom!”- Action Comics #400/2- May 1971
Superman: From the ‘30s to the ‘80s- Crown Publishers, Inc. New York- 1983- First Edition
Foreword by Jenette Kahn, President and Publisher, DC Comics Inc.
Introduction by E. Nelson Bridwell, Editor DC Comics Inc.
[“Superman, Champion of the Oppressed”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #1- Summer 1939
[“War in San Monte”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #1/2- Summer 1939
[“The Challenge of Luthor”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #4- Spring 1940
[“The Light”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #13- November/December 1941
[“The Archer”]- Superman (Vol. 1) #13/2- November/December 1941
“Man or Superman?”- Superman (Vol. 1) #17- July/August 1942
“Case of the Funny Paper Crimes”- Superman (Vol. 1) #19- November/December 1942
“Superman, Matinee Idol”- Superman (Vol. 1) #19/4- November/December 1942
“America’s Secret Weapon”- Superman (Vol. 1) #23- July/August 1943
“The Mysterious Mr. Mxyztplk!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #30/4- September/October 1944
“Lois Lane, Superwoman”- Superman (Vol. 1) #45- March/April 1947
“The Battle of the Atoms!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #38- January/February 1946
“Black Magic on Mars”- Superman (Vol. 1) #62- January/February 1950
“The Girls in Superman’s Life”- Superman (Vol. 1) #78/4- September/October 1952
“The Terrible Trio”- Superman (Vol. 1) #88/3- March 1954
“The Girl in Superman’s Past!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #129/3- May 1959
“The Supergirl from Krypton!”- Action Comics #252/3- May 1959
“The Super-Duel in Space”- Action Comics #242- July 1958
“How Luthor Met Superboy!”- Adventure Comics #271- April 1960
“The Showdown Between Luthor and Superman!”- Superman (Vol. 1) #164- October 1963
“The Origin of Superman!”- Limited Collector’s Edition C-31- October/November 1974
“The Pied Piper of Steel”- Action Comics #398- March 1971
“Superman, You’re Dead…Dead…Dead!”- Action Comics #399- April 1971
“The Miraculous Return of Jonathan Kent!”- Action Comics #507- May 1980
“The Secret World of Jonathan Kent!”- Action Comics #508- June 1980
Another note: I realize that the origin of Superman that was reprinted in
Superman: From the ‘30s to the ‘80s was also in
The Amazing World of DC Superman Edition but to my knowledge the
Limited Collector's Edition was it's first appearence.