Superman Through the Ages! Forum

Superman Comic Books! => Superman! => Topic started by: Continental Op on October 29, 2005, 05:31:03 PM



Title: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: Continental Op on October 29, 2005, 05:31:03 PM
I started drawing up one of my time-wastin' comics "lists" again and I thought I'd ask for help with it.

This one is for every character who knew that Clark was Superman's secret ID.

The list only applies to characters who did not learn and then forget (or die) within the course of a single story. Superman hypnotized a lot of people or used Amnesium on them  to protect his secret ID almost as soon as they learned it, for example. And I won't bother to include any time-travelers who mainly lived in the future, such as the Legion of Super-Heroes and their enemies, since Superman's secret ID was generally accepted as becoming public knowledge after his lifetime.

I probably overlooked at least a few good ones (it was a surprisingly large group by the time the Crisis rolled around). Feel free to post suggestions.

Earth-Two Superman:

Lois Lane-Kent
Power Girl
Batman
Robin
Catwoman
Most (all?) of the Justice Society
Merton

Earth-One Superman

Ma and Pa Kent (deceased)

Batman
Robin / Nightwing (Dick Grayson)
Supergirl
Pete Ross
Jon Ross
Green Lantern (Hal)
The Flash (Barry)
Wonder Woman
Aquaman
Green Arrow
The Atom
Hawkman
Hawkwoman
Black Canary
Zatanna
Elongated Man
Lori Lemaris
Krypto
Super-Monkey
All Phantom Zone prisoners
The Supermen Emergency Squad of Kandor
Some (all?) inhabitants of Kandor
All members of the Superman Revenge Squad
Kobra
Vartox
Ambush Bug
Rokk and Sorban
CW Saturn
Lyle Corliss
Ryan Lowell (later hypnotized to forget)
Brainiac
All Bizarro-Supermen
The Parasite
All Superman/Clark Kent robots
The Sandman of Earth-1 (Garrett Sanford)
Karb-Brak
The Spectre
The Thanagarians
President John F. Kennedy (deceased)
Destiny
The Quakerer
The Monitor and Harbinger (knew everything)
All comic readers of Earth-Prime
Numerous other aliens

Characters who may well have known, but I donít remember it being specifically shown:

Red Tornado
Firestorm
Alfred
The Phantom Stranger
The Guardians
Fred and Edna Danvers
Mongul
Deadman
Sue Dibny


Title: Re: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: TELLE on October 29, 2005, 11:58:55 PM
I know that the Guardians know.  Can't quote chapter and verse but the "Old Timer" from Last Son of Krypton knew and had a chat with Clark in Kryptonese, or something.

The Kandor question is interesting: I remember one or two stories involving Kandorians who wheren't hep to the secret id thing.  Did I imagine this?  Kandor is a city the size of New York, I suppose there are people there who don't follow the news or know anything about history.  Kind of like finding an objective juror for the Michael Jackson case --who hasn't heard of Michael Jackson?

What about the wives of Justice Leaguers besides Sue Dibny?

It's funny how all aliens know.

Bat-mite?  Mxy must know.

E2 JSA?  The JSA is funny: more of a club where men dress up to relax.  More secretive?  Do they know each others' or are they all still into the "secret identity" thing?  The JLA was less macho, more UN.  Would Zatanna tell her father?  His career started around the same time as Superman's.

That Mynah bird from "Clark Kent's Minah Dilemna".


Title: Re: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: MatterEaterLad on October 30, 2005, 12:10:57 AM
Mr. Xavier and his evil overlords...I don't think you list them...


Title: Re: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: Klar Ken T5477 on October 30, 2005, 01:51:32 AM
Zor-El and Allura


Title: Re: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: Uncle Mxy on October 30, 2005, 09:03:10 AM
Steve Allen


Title: Re: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: Johnny Nevada on October 30, 2005, 12:57:45 PM
An amendment to the list, but I'd assume it's actually "everyone breathing and over the age of 3 on Earth-Prime", not just comic fans---given Superman's level of being a cultural icon in the "real world". ;-)

I'll also add:

- the aliens in the Superboy story from the 80's where he's trapped on another planet as a "theme park" attraction


Title: Re: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: Gernot on October 31, 2005, 03:46:45 PM
I'm not sure, but I think The Teen Titans may've known.  

Also, in the Pre-satellite days of the JLA, they did NOT share their identities with one another, though some members shared the info amongst themselves (Superman/Batman, Flash/Green Lantern).  

Mr. Mxyzptlk did NOT know Superman had another identity as Clark Kent, as shown in the story where he changed the gender of everybody on the planet (there was a Clara Kent, but no Miss Mxyzptlk, and that's how Superman knew Mxy was behind his troubles).


Title: Re: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: TELLE on November 01, 2005, 04:36:15 AM
Quote from: "Gernot"
I'm not sure, but I think The Teen Titans may've known.  

Also, in the Pre-satellite days of the JLA, they did NOT share their identities with one another, though some members shared the info amongst themselves (Superman/Batman, Flash/Green Lantern).  

Mr. Mxyzptlk did NOT know Superman had another identity as Clark Kent, as shown in the story where he changed the gender of everybody on the planet (there was a Clara Kent, but no Miss Mxyzptlk, and that's how Superman knew Mxy was behind his troubles).


 aha!

Side note: I guess the Atom was the only JLA member who could travel to the cave-quarters in "pre-Satellite" days, via land-line I guess. :D


Title: Re: The Superman Secret ID Club
Post by: Gernot on November 01, 2005, 09:07:20 AM
Wellll...

Green Lantern COULD have, if he'd WANTED!  

 :lol: