This is the first part of a four part story by Tom Peyer and Mark Waid that came out in 1996.
I have very mixed feelings about putting this on the site, but for some reason I seem to have done it. I consider it to be "alternate universe" dark-age Superman, kind of like how Lois & Clark was.
http://superman.nu/tales3/identity/1/I'm going back to Maggin, Bates, and some rare stuff from the 1950s after this!